The
Analysis of the Intrinsic Elements of The Black Cat, Cat In the Rain, and The
Old Man and the Sea.
|
|
The
Black Cat
|
Cat
in the Rain
|
The
Old Man and the Sea
|
|
Author
|
Edgar A. Poe
|
Ernest Hemingway
|
Ernest Hemingway
|
|
Plot
|
Exposition
The narrator is scheduled to die the following day,
so he’s about to pen his experience of life that has made his life go bad. (Page
1 paragraph 1).
From his infancy he’s fond of animal, and the animal
that he loved the most was named Pluto, a black cat which it furs entirely
black. (Page 2 paragraph 1 & 2).
Raising action
One night, when he was intoxicated, he fancied that Pluto
avoided his presence, so he took off one of Pluto’s eye. (page 2 paragraph
3,4,5,6)
In another day he hung Pluto (Page 3 line 1-21).
and on the night of the day which his cruelty to Pluto
has done, his house is on fire, (page 3 paragraph 1)
when he visited the ruins of his burnt house
he saw a bas relief upon the white surface, the figure of a gigantic cat,
after that he felt terror caused by hung Pluto (page 3 paragraph 2, page 4
paragraph 1&2)
On the other day, he found a cat who look like Pluto,
but he has some splotch of white fur in his breast. He loved that cat but by
the following day, he hates the creature. (page 4 paragraph 3, 4, 5) (page 5)
he was thinking hard and confused how to hide the
corpse of his wife (page 6 paragraph 3)
climax
he tries to kill the cat with an axe but it arrested
by the hand of his wife, he got mad by the interference of his wife, then he
killed her. (page 6 paragraph 2)
falling action
he inserted the corpse of his wife into the wall (page
7 paragraph 1)
Resolution
he hit the wall by a cane and the police saw the
corpse of the narrator’s wife in the broken wall(page 8 paragraph 2)
they saw the condition of the narrator’s wife corpse
(page 8 last paragraph)
|
Exposition
When two Americans visited Italy to enjoy their
holiday (paragraph 1, 2, and 3).
Raising Action
When the American wife stood at the window, she saw
a kitty under the dripping green table, and she wanted that kitty badly, and
she tries to get that kitty. (paragraph 4, 5, and 7)
The cat was gone. So she goes back to her room.
(paragraph 8 and 9)
Climax
she told everything that she wanted, but her husband
just shut her out and keep reading, and she keep talking, but her husband
told her to shut up and get something to read, she feels rejected and sad
feel like a kitty whose crouched in the dripping table in the rain. (paragraph
10, 11, and 13)
falling action
the girl stops talking and she looking out of the
window (paragraph 14)
Resolution
When someone knock the door, and it was the maid who
bought her a big tortoiseshell cat. (paragraph 15 and 16)
|
Exposition
There
was an old man who fished alone in a skiff in the Gulf Stream and he had gone
eighty-four days without taking any fish. In the first forty days he was
accompanied by a boy. But then the boy had gone to another boat by his parent’s
order. (page 1 paragraph 1)
Raising Action
On the day eighty-fifth the old man went to sail and
wishes that he will get a fish. He thought that in the day of eighty-fifth he
should fish the day well. Then he looks at one hundred fathoms down a marlin
was eating the sardines that covered the point and the shank of the hook
where the hand-forged hook projected from the head of the small tuna. (page
10 paragraph 9 line 5-7)
The old man struggle to get the fish is really hard.
(page 11 paragraph 2 -page 33 paragraph 9)
Climax
When he got the marlin, a shark came because of the
smell of the marlin’s blood, then the old man endeavored to kill the shark,
but the last shark can’t be killed by the old man and it eats the marlin.
(page 28 paragraph 3.- page 33 paragraph 9)
Falling action
The shark had caught the most part of the fish, and
the old man pay no more attention to the shark (page 33paragraph 1-10)
He spat into the ocean and said, “eat that, galanos.
And make a dream you’ve killed a man” (page 33 paragraph 11)
Resolution
Finally, he arrived at the shack and then he slept
and dreaming about the lion while the boy was watching him. (page 36 last
paragraph)
|
|
Setting
|
The physical setting:
1.
At the narrator’s
house. (page 2 paragraph 4)
2.
At the narrator’s
burnt house (ruined house) (page 3 paragraph 3)
3.
At the cellar,
a place which he had killed his wife. (page 6 paragraph 3)
|
The physical
setting is in the Italian Hotel
which an American couple stay to spend their Holiday in the Italy, it was a
great place, which was their room in the 2nd floor and faces the
sea, and it also faced the public garden and the war monument. (paragraph 1,
line 2)
|
The physical setting:
1.
Old man’s
terrace (page 1, paragraph 5)
2.
On the old
man shack (page 2, paragraph 2)
3.
On the old
man skiff. (all the time when he fishes in the story)
4.
Sea (all of
the part of the story)
|
|
The Atmosphere Setting:
1.
Uncontrolled,
he was intoxicated and he no longer knew himself, his fancy already make him
do something cruel to Pluto, it is taking off one of Pluto’s eyes. (page 2
paragraph 4)
2.
Panic, by
the fire who burnt his house so the narrator, his wife, and the servant
escape from the conflagration. (page 3 paragraph 2)
3.
He felt
worried about the horror effect after he hung Pluto. (page 4 paragraph 1
& 2)
4.
He was
surprised when his wife had called his attention to the character of the mark
of white hair in his cat, he soon realizes it look like GALLOWS. (page 5
paragraph 4)
5.
He confused
and anxious about what should he do with the corpse of his wife, and where
should he hide that corpse. He really confused and anxious. (page6 paragraph
3)
|
The Atmosphere setting is boring, flat. (In
the conversation which the couple have) their conversation is too boring
because of he shout the girl out but the girl keep talking.
|
The Atmosphere setting:
1.
Wary, when
he looked down into the water and watched the lines that went straight down
into the dark of water. (page 8 paragraph 3 line 4)
2.
Tight, and
hopefully, when he talks himself when he saw marlin was about to eat his
sardines. (page 11 paragraph 4 line 3-5)
3.
Glee, when
he felt something hard and unbelievably heavy, he thought that it was the
weight of the fish. (page 11 paragraph 6)
4.
Mad ,
because the shark had eaten the most part of his marlin, so he spat into the
ocean (page 33 paragraph 10 line 2)
|
|
|
The social setting is:
1.
He and his family were
fond of animals. (page 1
paragraph 2)
2.
A myth
which regarded all black cats as witches in disguise. (page2 paragraph 1)
3.
The narrator’s
life is change caused by alcohol addict which has made him be a
rage man either with his wife or his pets,
and for his addiction result is he killed her wife. (the whole story)
|
The social setting is:
1.
The
American couple is different from others, they both were an immigrant, and
they both only the American which is stay in the hotel. (paragraph 1 line 1)
2.
Good manner
and kindness, the padrone shows his kindness to the visitors by sent a maid
which bought an umbrella to accompany the American wife looking for the kitty
under the table out of the hotel. (paragraph 7 line 3)
3.
The husband
which is indifferent with his wife, he keeps enjoy his reading. (it shows on
the conversation which they have)
|
The social setting is:
1.
Manolin was
a good boy, although he really wanted to be with the old man, but he obeyed
his parents (page 1 paragraph 1)
2.
The old man
is a kind man although many of the fisherman made fun of the old man but he
wasn’t angry. (page 1 paragraph 5 line 1)
3.
The old man
believes that 85 is a lucky number. (page 3 paragraph 3 line 2)
4.
The old man
picked up only a straggler from the albacore that were feeding. (page 10
paragraph 5 line 2)
5.
The old man
keep praying for killing the fish and he also pray for the death fish (page 17 paragraph 10 line
4&5- page 18 line 1&2)
|
|
|
Theme
|
Transformation,
The
narrator's transformation via alcohol from a family guy who loves his wife
and pets to a moody maniac who cuts out his cat's eye, hangs his cat, and
eventually murder his wife. This transformation is psychological and the
result of the narrator's addiction of alcohol.
|
Dissatisfaction
she came from
a long way off to look up at the war monument, and going to spend the
holidays with her husband, but that was a rainy day, so they both stuck in
the hotel, they could go nowhere, they stuck in their room like imprisonment
and her husband always shout her out, no matter what she is talking about, he
always keeps reading and ignore her.
|
Struggle
The whole story shows us about the old man struggle
in life, in fishing, and when he try to catch marlin, and when he tried to
kill the sharks to keep his fish.
|
|
Point
of view
|
First person central:
the story tells about the narrator’s life and used
word “I, me, my” although the narrator’s name was anonymous.
|
Third Person Limited:
the author describe the characters through what can
be seen, heard, or thought.
|
Third Person Omniscient:
The author describe the characters widely through
his thought and behaviour even guessing and commenting what the character had
in his mind
|
|
Style
and Tone
|
Style
of Edgar Allan Poe in this story is gothic. It shows many horror, scary, and cruelty.
And the tone is Ironic, there are many household events happen which was called by anonymous
narrator as “a mere household events” which is in this story the narrator
always did something cruel and then he felt guilty and he goes on to blame "the Fiend
Intemperance" which caused the "radical alteration" in his
mood. And he always do that but he continued doing
something crueler again and again.
|
Style
of Ernest Hemingway in this story is simple, he writes really in a simple way
but he could make all of the girl’s feelings out, it really conveys the deep
feeling of the girl.
And the tone is Controlled, there’s a conflict
between restraint and rebellion present in this story, but Hemingway only
suggests it. The husband and wife are at odds and discontent with one
another, but they don't talk about it. Instead, the tension lies in their lack
of real interaction. There's an unhappiness that they are studiously
avoiding, but trapped as they are in their room on that rainy day, as each
other's only company and as the only Americans at the hotel, the awkwardness
becomes pretty concentrated.
|
Style
of Ernest Hemingway in this story is detail, he writes the story really in
detail way and so distinctly, so the reader could imagine all the way of the
plot of the story and understand the act of the character clearly.
And the tone is factual,serious, but sympathic , the conversation shows the old man struggles
which is taken so seriously, there is not really any humor, and the boy
always taking care of the old man such as serve him in any way he could do.
|
|
Symbolism
|
The
black cat, it is a symbol of witches in disguise based to the
ancient popular nation. And soon the narrator believes it, it proved based on
after he hung Pluto, he found so many accidents within distinct reason, when
his house going through the conflagration, bas relief upon the white surface
of his burnt house, cat on the head of the corpse of his wife.
White
splotch which is look like gallows on the breast of his second cat, it is a
symbol of the narrator’s cruelty to Pluto, it remains the narrator that he
hung Pluto.
|
The
cat under a dripping table in the rain, it a symbol of the American wife, in paragraph 4,
it tells us that a cat was crouched under one of the dripping green tables,
the dripping green table is symbol of the hotel which is the American wife
stay, and the cat crouched so that she would not get wet, it symbols that the
cat couldn’t go anywhere, just like the American wife who stuck in the hotel
like imprisonment. And I think it also symbol of the American wife feeling,
we know that the cat under a table is perhaps just a cringing, drippy,
unhappy cat under a table.
|
Sea, it is a symbol
of the old man’s journey and struggle.
Manolin, it is a symbol
of kindness, he like to serve the old man in any way, he takes care of him,
and he obey his parents, that’s such a kind of good boy.
Marlin, it symbol
of successful on fishing.
Shark, symbol of
vigour that hard to be conquered.
|
|
Irony
|
Dramatic irony
One
morning, in cool blood, I slipped a noose about its neck and hung it to the
limb of a tree;-hung it with the tears streaming from my eyes and with the
bitterest remorse at my heart ~
it is hard to believe that he hung Pluto because of he knew that the cat
loves him, he hung it and he aware, but he felt guilty .(page 3 line 14- 21)
|
Dramatic irony
The wife liked him. She liked the deadly serious
way he received any complaints. She liked his
dignity. She liked the way he wanted to serve her. She liked the
way
he felt about being a hotel-keeper. She liked his old, heavy face and big
hands~what has the padrone done
is completely different with the husband of the American wife(page 1
paragraph 6)
|
Dramatic irony
he was an old
man who fished alone in a skiff and he had gone eighty-four days now without
taking a fish, and the boy’s parents that the old man was now
definitely and finally salao, which is the worst from of unlucky~ at the first the people think that he’s not success
in fishing, but at the end of the story they respected him because of his
successful catching a huge marlin, although just left of it skeleton.(page 1
paragraph 1)
|
|
Verbal irony
I looked around
triumphantly, and said to myself— "Here at least, then, my labor has not
been in vain." ~it’s hard to believe that he
didn’t feel guilty and sad after killing
his wife and insert her
corpse in the wall, instead of saying like he has done such a success good thing(page 7 paragraph 1)
|
Verbal irony
‘I
wanted it so much,’ she said. ‘I don’t know why I wanted it so much. I wanted
it so much. I wanted that poor kitty. It isn’t any fun to be a poor kitty out
in the rain.’~ she said that
she wanted that kitty but by the word that she’s been saying, we can conclude
that she just wants her husband to pay more attention to her.(page 2
paragraph 1 line 10&11)
|
Verbal irony
He
spat out into the ocean and said,’ eat that, galanos. And make a dream you’ve
killed a man.’~ it contrasts
with his condition, he didn’t want the shark to eat his marlin, he’s already
fought the shark before to keep his fish but in the end he let the shark eat
it in terms of he’s been so tired, bites and he could no longer fight in his
condition. (page 33 paragraph 10 line 3)
|
No comments:
Post a Comment